Christian Balog beschreibt den Wein wie folgt:
Dichter Kern, schöne satte Frucht am Gaumen, fleischig mit reifem zupackendem Tannin, balancierte Säure. eher kräftiges und würziges Finale. 90-92 Punkte.
James Suckling bewertet den Chateau Montviel 2018 Pomerol wie folgt:
Blueberries and slate with hints of lavender and rosemary. Full body and firm, silky tannins. Chewy finish. Best ever?
Lisa Perrotti Brown bewertet den Chateau Montviel 2018 Pomerol wie folgt:
Deep purple-black colored, the 2018 Montviel leaps from the glass with bold black cherries, black raspberries and warm red plums scents plus touches of garrigue, lavender. Sichuan pepper and tree bark. Full-bodied, rich and opulent, it delivers wonderfully ripe, plush tannins and a long pepper-laced finish.
Antonio Galloni bewertet den Chateau Montviel 2018 Pomerol wie folgt:
The 2018 Montviel is a lush, forward Pomerol that will drink well with minimal cellaring. Black cherry, chocolate, leather, spice and menthol infuse this creamy, racy Pomerol. The 2018 is not especially complex. but it is tasty. Tasted two times.